The Conclave
How it works
The process

Six labs. Seven stages. One decision.

The Conclave doesn't ask one model — it forces six of them to argue, anonymized to each other, until a measurable majority converges on one answer. Here is what happens between the moment you hit submit and the PDF you get back.

The Process — ~30 minutes, fully visible while it runs
1. Briefing
The question and any attached documents are delivered to all six panelists at once.
2. Independent submissions
Each model writes its answer in isolation, before seeing the others.
3. Anonymized debate
Submissions are stripped of authorship and exchanged. Across multiple rounds, models challenge the strongest claims in each other's work and defend, rebut, or concede.
4. Live fact-checking
After round one, an off-panel model with web access searches for counter-evidence to each panelist's strongest claims and feeds it into the next round.
5. Judges deliberate
A separate panel of judge-model instances reads the full transcript and votes (Affirm / Remand / Dismiss).
6. Fresh-eyes audit
A model that wasn't part of the debate audits the consensus for groupthink.
7. Decision rendered
Names are de-anonymized; the final document — The Question, The Answer, The Reasoning, each model's closing statement, and Notable items — is written and downloadable as a PDF.

The room doesn't open until the panel's measured agreement score crosses a threshold. In practice that's by round four or five. If a model never agrees, its dissent is preserved in its closing statement.

Model selection

Six labs, one room.

Each panelist comes from a different lab — different training data, different priorities, different post-training reflexes. They genuinely disagree. When they still reach a majority, the answer survived the disagreement that produced it.

The Panel — each seat earns its keep
Claude Opus 4.8Anthropic
Long-form rigor. Holds positions under pressure without over-conceding.
GPT-5OpenAI
Step-by-step logic. Best at finding holes in the others' arguments.
Gemini 3.1 ProGoogle
Real-time web search. Brings facts the others have to reason about.
Grok 4xAI
Less hedged than the western trio. Willing to take and defend a contrarian line.
DeepSeek V4 ProDeepSeek · open-weight
Frontier reasoning trained outside the US labs. Different training distribution; different defaults.
Kimi K2.6Moonshot AI · open-weight
Trillion-parameter mixture-of-experts with extended reasoning. Long-context champion — best when the question has many moving parts. Different RLHF lineage than the western models.
+ Fact-checker — off-panel, kicks in after round 1
Perplexity Sonar ProPerplexity · Llama 3.3 70B + live web
Different shape than the others — a fine-tune of Meta's open Llama 3.3 70B paired with a live web index and citation engine. After round 1 it searches the web for counter-evidence to each panelist's strongest claims; the rebuttal brief is fed into the next debate round.

Frontier-tier only. No smaller substitutes when an API is unavailable — the seat goes empty rather than getting filled by a weaker model.

Start Gallery
Sign in

Gallery

Past deliberations of the Conclave. Six AI models locked in a room until a majority agrees.

Newest Popular
Will Starcloud be able to solve thermal management for space-based data centers at scale? See the sectin entitled, "Thermal Management" in the included PDF.
No, Starcloud will not be able to solve thermal management for a 5 GW space-based data center as currently described in the white paper.
Black smoke
Panel:Gemini, DeepSeek, and Claude
May 11, 2026
Will the WHO declare Hantavirus a Public Health Emergency of International Concern this Year?
No, the WHO will not declare hantavirus a Public Health Emergency of International Concern (PHEIC) in 2026.
Gray smoke
Panel:DeepSeek, Gemini, GPT-5, and 2 more
1 view · May 11, 2026
Will the Hanta virus kill more than 100 people this month?
No, the Hanta virus will not kill more than 100 people globally this month.
Gray smoke
Panel:GPT-5, DeepSeek, Gemini, and 2 more
May 11, 2026
What is the best strategy, balancing risk and reward, for this Kalshi proposition? Commodities · Oil & Gas Oil Price (WTI) on Friday? 2,011 Begins on Friday · May 15, 12:00am EDT $ 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 . 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 ▼ 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 . 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 % Updated 2d 20h ago May 1 May 5 May 7 May 9 May 11 $90.00 $95.00 $100.00 $105.00 $110.00 Above 101.99 $54,921 vol 1W 1M Chance $88.99 or below Yes 15¢ No 86¢ $89 to 89.99 Yes 3¢ No 98¢ $90 to 90.99 Yes 5¢ No 96¢ $91 to 91.99 Yes 5¢ No 96¢ $92 to 92.99 Yes 4¢ No 97¢ $93 to 93.99 Yes 4¢ No 97¢ $94 to 94.99 Yes 4¢ No 97¢ $95 to 95.99 Yes 6¢ No 96¢ $96 to 96.99 Yes 5¢ No 96¢ $97 to 97.99 Yes 5¢ No 96¢ $98 to 98.99 Yes 6¢ No 95¢ $99 to 99.99 Yes 5¢ No 96¢ $100 to 100.99 Yes 6¢ No 96¢ $101 to 101.99 Yes 5¢ No 96¢ $102 or above Yes 33¢ No 68¢ Hide markets
The best strategy, balancing risk and reward, is to immediately buy "No" on the "$102 or above" bin at 68¢, sized at quarter-Kelly (~2,500–3,500 contracts), with the option to add a center-bin ladder on Friday morning if volatility and pric…
White smoke
Panel:Grok, GPT-5, Gemini, and 2 more
May 11, 2026
What will the price per barrel be for oil on July 1st, 2026?
The price of Brent crude oil on July 1, 2026, will be $101 per barrel.
Gray smoke
Panel:GPT-5, Gemini, DeepSeek, and 2 more
May 11, 2026
What will the oil price per barrel be on July 1st, 2026?
The price of Brent crude oil on July 1, 2026, will be $91 per barrel.
Gray smoke
Panel:Kimi, Grok, GPT-5, and 3 more
May 11, 2026
What will the ISM Manufacturing PMI be for May?
The ISM Manufacturing PMI for May 2026 will be 51.9, indicating continued expansion but with mild deceleration from April's 52.7.
White smoke
Panel:Gemini, GPT-5, Claude, and 2 more
May 10, 2026
Should AI replace human juries in low-stakes civil cases?
AI should not replace human juries in low-stakes civil cases at this time due to unresolved legal, epistemic, and reliability barriers.
Black smoke REMAND
Panel:Gemini, DeepSeek, Kimi, and 3 more
May 10, 2026
Who will file for an IPO first, Anthropic or OpenAI?
Anthropic will file for an IPO before OpenAI.
Gray smoke
Panel:Grok, Claude, DeepSeek, and 3 more
1 view · May 10, 2026
Should remote work be the default for knowledge workers?
No, remote work should not be the default for knowledge workers.
No verdict
Panel:Kimi, Gemini, DeepSeek, and 3 more
May 10, 2026
← Newer Page 8 of 8 Older →