BLACK SMOKE REMAND 6 advocates 2026-05-11

Should AI replace human juries in low-stakes civil cases?

No majority verdict was reached.

The Bottom Line

AI should not replace human juries in low-stakes civil cases at this time due to unresolved legal, epistemic, and reliability barriers.

Sign up — get full positions →
Free account unlocks every speaker's full closing. The audio debate and full PDF come with the paid tier (launching soon).
Argument

The Reasoning

Per-speaker

Closing Positions — one sentence per speaker (free tier)

Mid-debate

Concessions

Who deliberated
Gemini 3.1 Pro DeepSeek R1 Kimi K2.6 Grok 4 GPT-5 Claude Opus 4.7